Paying Your Bill

Most of our companies bill you directly for your coverage. We strongly recommend that you pay directly to your insurance company.

Some of our companies offer online payment options:

Drive Insurance from Progressive

Erie Insurance

For other companies, you can mail your check direct. If you don't have your bill, be sure to write your policy number on your check. Here are addresses and phone numbers for several of our companies:

Erie and Niagara Insurance Association
8800 Sheridan Drive
Box 9062
Williamsville, New York 14231-9062
800-234-9876

Allegany Co-op Insurance Company
9 North Branch Rd.
Cuba, NY 14727
800-333-1679

Genesee Patrons Coop Insurance Company
218 East Main Street
Batavia, New York 14020-2282
Phone (585) 343-7307
800-343-6496

United Frontier Mutual Insurance Company
195 Davison Road
Lockport, New York 14094-3333.
800-352-0908

Please give us a call if your company isn't listed here or if you have unresolved problems that we can assist you with.