Reporting an Accident or Claim

In most cases, you should call us first whenever you need to report an accident or claim at 589-4477 or 800-346-8588. Here are notes and after-hours numbers for several of our companies:

Erie Insurance
After hours service: 800-367-3743
Glass Claims can be reported directly: 800-552-3743
Online reporting

Drive Insurance From Progressive
All claims must be reported directly to Progressive: 800-925-2886
Online reporting

Erie and Niagara Insurance Association
800-234-9876

Allegany Co-op Insurance Company
After Hours 24 Hour Emergency Claim Service: 800-501-5787

Genesee Patrons Coop Insurance Company
800-343-6496

United Frontier Mutual Insurance Company
800-352-0908
After hours: David Langendorfer, 716-417-2242
Online Information

Countryway Insurance
Business Hours (Monday thru Friday 8:00am - 4:30am EST) 1-800-828-6862
After hours: 1-888-223-3649

You can also reach us after hours with any claim emergencies. Just call our regular phone number; our answering system will give you home numbers of staff members who are on-call.